After looking at the generic gaming subscriptions on consoles last week – Xbox Live, Playstation Plus and the forthcoming service from Nintendo – I also wanted to take a look at a couple of other things I am currently subscribing to. They are both on Xbox One, but there are similar services on other platforms like PS4 and PC. I have recently signed up to Xbox Game Pass and I am a long-time subscriber to EA Access.
Xbox Game Pass
This service is kind of like Netflix or Amazon Prime, but for games. You pay a fee each month and then a whole host of games is available to you to download and play within that. As would be expected, these aren’t recent games in most cases and the selection is fairly random. As such, this won’t be any good for anyone looking for new games, or who has played most of these games back when they were new. However, I think it works for two kinds of gamers. The first are those people who are fairly new to Xbox One. The chance to play through the old Gears of War games, Halo 5, the Bioshock series, Sunset Overdrive – there is a ton of great gaming here that will keep newcomers entertained for months to come. The second is people, like me, who have missed out on a few of the more indie titles available. A couple of them I have already played like Braid or Hexic 2, but I’m currently taking the chance to play through Hue. It’s easy to miss these gems amongst all the latest big releases so I am pleased to have the chance to play them.
That said, I do think that Xbox Game Pass is ultimately not worth the money for a consistent subscription. At £7.99 a month it would be a bargain if it consistently had new(ish) games that were worth playing but the reality is that once you are done with the few that you missed there aren’t enough, good enough, games added to the service on the monthly basis. Once I’ve completed the games I mentioned above, I will be cancelling.
What I won’t be cancelling is my EA Access subscription. Whilst this comes with a clear caveat – it only gives you games from the publisher Electronic Arts (EA) – the service itself is great, and a bargain to boot. You get two different aspects here. Firstly, much like Xbox Game Pass, there is the EA Access ‘Vault’ where plenty of EA’s slightly older games reside for subscribers to play. It always includes their older sports games – currently Madden NFL 17, FIFA 17 etc and quite a few others. For example, I am currently catching up with Mass Effect: Andromeda via my subscription. The second aspect is a combination of early access and discounts on new games. When EA is publishing a new games those with an EA Access subscription get to play a 10 hour trial of the game a week ahead of release. A recent example here is when tried out Need for Speed Payback via this service. Finally, you can get a 10% discount on those games if you have liked them at the end of your trial.
This second part is the real key to setting this apart from the other gaming subscriptions. All of the others that offer free games offer almost entirely old ones. So there’s a good chance you’ve already played the best ones anyway. With EA Access you get to play new games, in fact you get to play them early. And at only £20 for a whole year it’s a bargain – you could easily make that back just on the 10% savings if you buy a few new games from EA over a year. Unless you never play EA games, this subscription is great.
The concept of these subscriptions is great – pay a small fee and you have loads and loads of games available to play. However, without a consistent stream of new games this can get stale once you’ve played all the ones you want to. To return to the Netflix/Amazon comparison above – they are now making their own TV shows and have new release movies on a regular basis. Until Xbox Game Pass can match that kind of quality new content in gaming, it will not be something I subscribe to. EA Access is a well done model for how gaming subscriptions could work, but of course is only one publisher. If Xbox Game Pass was ever able to match that model across multiple publishers – well, then it would be a no brainer!
Click here to purchase an monthly subscription to Xbox Game Pass from Amazon.co.uk:
Click here to purchase an annual subscription to EA Access from Amazon.co.uk: